无充气经锁骨下入路腔镜甲状腺癌根治术治疗单侧甲状腺乳头状癌的临床疗效及学习曲线

Effectiveness and learning curve of gasless trans-subclavian approach endoscopic thyroidectomy for unilateral papillary thyroid carcinoma

  • 摘要:
    背景 无充气经锁骨下入路腔镜甲状腺癌根治术(gasless trans-subclavian approach endoscopic thyroidectomy,GTAET)的临床应用逐渐增多,其手术安全性、彻底性、可推广性尚待研究。目的 分析GTAET治疗单侧甲状腺乳头状癌(papillary thyroid carcinoma,PTC)的临床疗效及手术学习曲线。方法 回顾性选取2023年1 — 12月解放军总医院第一医学中心甲状腺(疝)外科收治行单侧甲状腺癌根治术的PTC患者,根据手术方式分为GTAET组和颈前弧形切口颈白线入路开放手术(linea alba cervicalis approach open thyroidectomy,LACAT)组。比较两组手术安全性、彻底性、患者主观评价等临床疗效指标,并采用多因素累积和分析法(cumulative sum analysis,CUSUM)及最佳拟合曲线分析GTAET学习曲线。结果 共纳入PTC患者309例,根据手术方式分组,GTAET组患者60例,其中男性12例,女性48例,年龄(38.95±8.34)岁。LACAT组249例,男性75例,女性114例,年龄(41.66±10.70)岁。GTAET组女性占比更高(80% vs 60.3%,P=0.005),BMI水平更低(22.86±3.11) kg/m2 vs (25.30±4.19) kg/m2 ,P<0.001,两组年龄、合并桥本病率、肿瘤位置差异均无统计学意义(P>0.05)。相较于LACAT组,GTAET组手术时间更长(104.63±22.29) min vs (67.88±15.69) min,P<0.001,术中出血量减少(17.65± 2.83) mL vs (19.49±3.34) mL,P<0.001,术后引流量增多(82.12±28.74) mL vs (68.90±21.08) mL,P=0.01。两组术后住院时长、多灶癌率、中央区清扫淋巴结数、转移淋巴结数差异均无统计学意义(P>0.05)。术后并发症方面,LACAT组出现暂时性甲状旁腺功能减退20例,GTAET组6例,两组暂时性甲状旁腺功能减退发生率差异无统计学意义(P>0.05),GTAET组未见其他并发症出现。GTAET组患者切口美观满意度评分、颈前感觉满意度评分均高于LACAT组(P<0.05)。GTAET组出现术后吞咽牵拉感(6.7% vs 19.6%,P=0.019)、颈前区感觉异常(2.3% vs 12.7%,P=0.039)的患者均少于 LACAT 组。GTAET组内亚组间比较,T1b期患者清扫淋巴结数目多于T1a期患者(P<0.05)。其余各亚组临床资料差异无统计学意义(P >0.05)。GTAET 学习曲线的最佳拟合方程为 y=-1.937+0.78x-0.02x2 +(1.37E-4)x3 ,学习曲线拐点出现在第 27 例。结论  GTAET治疗单侧PTC安全可行,在患者美容满意度及颈前功能保护方面优于LACAT,其腔镜和传统手术相兼容的操作模式,可有效降低手术操作难度,使该术式具有较短的学习曲线,值得临床推广。

     

    Abstract:
    Abstract: Background The clinical application of gasless trans-subclavian approach endoscopic thyroidectomy (GTAET) is gradually increasing, but its safety, thoroughness and popularization should be further investigated. Objective To analyze the clinical efficacy and surgical learning curve of GTAET for unilateral papillary thyroid carcinoma (PTC).Methods The patients with PTC who underwent unilateral radical thyroidectomy in the Department of Thyroid (Hernia) Surgery, the First Medical Center, Chinese PLA General Hospital from January 2023 to December 2023 were retrospectively selected, the patients were divided into the GTAET group and the linea alba cervicalis approach open thyroidectomy (LACAT) group according to the surgical approach. The clinical efficacy indicators including surgical safety, thoroughness, and patient subjective evaluations were compared, and cumulative sum analysis (CUSUM) and best-fit curve analysis was used to analyze the learning curve of GTAET.Results A total of 309 PTC patients were included and grouped according to the surgical approach. There were 60 patients in the GTAET group, including 12 males and 48 females, with an average age of (38.95±8.34) years. The LACAT group included 249 patients, with 75 males and 174 females, with an average age of (41.66±10.70) years. The GTAET group had a higher proportion of females 80% vs 60.3%, P<0.05 and lower BMI levels (22.86±3.11 kg/m2 vs 25.30±4.19 kg/m2 , P<0.001). There were no significant differences between the two groups in age, the prevalence of Hashimoto's thyroiditis and tumor location (P>0.05). Compared with the LACAT group, the GTAET group had longer operation time (104.63±22.29 min vs 67.88±15.69 min,P<0.001), less operation blood loss (17.65±2.83 mL vs 19.49±3.34 mL, P<0.001), and increased postoperative drainage (82.12±28.74 mL vs 68.90±21.08 mL, P= 0.01), with significant differences. There were no statistical differences in postoperative hospital stay, multifocal carcinoma rate, the number of dissected and metastatic central lymph nodes (P>0.05). In terms of postoperative complications, 20 cases of transient hypoparathyroidism occurred in the LACAT group, compared to 6 cases in the GTAET group. There was no significant difference in the incidence of transient hypoparathyroidism between the two groups (P>0.05), and no other complications were observed in the GTAET group. The GTAET group demonstrated higher satisfaction scores for incision aesthetics (P<0.05) and anterior neck sensation (P<0.05) compared to LACAT group. The incidence of postoperative dysphagia with traction sensation (6.7% vs 19.6%, P= 0.019) and anterior neck sensory abnormalities (2.3% vs 12.7%, P=0.039) was lower in the GTAET group than in the LACAT group. In subgroup comparisons within the GTAET group, T1b stage patients had more dissected lymph nodes than T1a stage patients, with significant differences (P<0.05). There were no statistical differences in other clinical characteristics among subgroups. The best-fit equation for the GTAET learning curve was y=-1.937+0.78x-0.02x²+(1.37E-4)x³, the inflection point of learning curve appeared at the 27th case.Conclusion GTAET is a safe and feasible treatment for unilateral PTC, having the advantage over the LACAT in terms of cosmetic satisfaction and anterior neck function preservation. Its operational mode integrates endoscopic and traditional surgical techniques, can reduce the difficulty of procedure, contributing to a shorter learning curve, making it worthy of clinical promotion.

     

/

返回文章
返回