深刺足三里穴对心脏与外周血管自主神经活动的时相性协同调节:一项基于HRV与BPV同步分析的随机对照研究

Temporal synergistic modulation of cardiac and peripheral vascular autonomic function by deep acupuncture at ST36: A randomized controlled study based on simultaneous analysis of HRV and BPV

  • 摘要: 背景 足三里穴为针灸临床常用要穴,广泛应用于心血管及消化系统等多系统疾病的治疗,疗效确切。但深刺足三里对自主神经的调控模式尚缺乏客观定量依据。目的 观察足三里穴深刺(接近血管旁)对健康受试者心率变异性(heart rate variability,HRV)、血压变异性(blood pressure variability,BPV)、心输出量(cardiac output,CO)及动脉压力反射敏感性(baroreflex sensitivity,BRS)的影响,以阐明针刺对心血管自主神经的调节作用,从而为针灸“调气血”功效提供客观依据。方法 2025 年10 月至12 月在解放军总医院招募健康受试者,随机分为深刺组和浅刺组。两组均取足三里穴,深刺组在超声引导下用毫针直刺约30 mm,至胫前动脉分支处,行提插手法150 s 后出针;浅刺组进针约10 mm,未达血管且不行手法。在针刺前(T1)、针刺时(T2)、针刺后即刻(T3)、针刺后30 min(T4)及针刺后120 min(T5)同步采集心电、连续血压信号各5 min,分析HRV、BPV及CO的变化,并利用传递函数分析BRS的变化。结果 共纳入68 例受试者,深刺组34 例男15例,女19 例,年龄(26.2±3.2)岁,浅刺组34 例男16 例,女18 例,年龄(25.5±3.3)岁,两组基线资料差异无统计学意义(P>0.05)。HRV方面,深刺组的相邻RR间期差值均方根对数值(lnRMSSD)在T2、T3、T4 均较T1 升高(P均<0.01),T5 与T1 差异无统计学意义(P>0.05);浅刺组各时间段指标与T1 比较,差异均无统计学意义(P>0.05);组间比较,深刺组lnRMSSD的△T2(T1 ~ T2 的变化量)高于浅刺组(0.35±0.31 vs 0.13±0.32,P<0.01)。BPV方面,深刺组T2 的收缩压标准差(SBP-SD)和变异系数(SBP-CV)均较T1 升高(P均<0.01),其余时段与T1 比较差异无统计学意义(P>0.05);浅刺组各时间段的指标与T1比较差异均无统计学意义(P>0.05);组间比较,深刺组T2 的SBP-SD和SBP-CV均高于浅刺组SBP-SD:(6.5±2.6) mmHg vs (4.9±1.4) mmHg;SBP-CV:0.057±0.021 vs 0.042±0.011,P均<0.01。CO方面,交互效应不显著(P>0.05),时间效应显著(P<0.05),对时间效应进行事后成对比较显示T2、T3、T4 的CO均低于T1(P<0.05 或P<0.01)。BRS方面,深刺组的BRS增益在T3 时段较T1 时段升高(P<0.05)。浅刺组各时间段的指标与T1 比较,差异均无统计学意义(P>0.05);组间比较,深刺组T3 时段的BRS 增益高于浅刺组10.66 (6.81,17.76) ms/mmHg vs 8.37 (7.03,10.50) ms/mmHg,P<0.05。结论 足三里穴深刺对心脏和血管的自主神经均具有调节作用。于血管而言,主要呈现交感效应;在心脏方面,则以副交感效应为主要表现。本研究可为窦性心动过速、心脏神经官能症、直立性低血压等心血管疾病的治疗提供初步的临床参考。

     

    Abstract: Background Zusanli (ST36) is one of the most commonly used acupoints in acupuncture and has shown good therapeutic effects on cardiovascular and other systemic diseases. However, the autonomic nervous system modulation pattern of deep needling at ST36 still lacks objective quantitative evidence. Objective To observe the effects of deep needling (near the blood vessel) at Zusanli on heart rate variability (HRV), blood pressure variability (BPV), cardiac output (CO), and baroreflex sensitivity (BRS) in healthy subjects, thereby elucidating the regulatory effect of acupuncture on cardiovascular autonomic nerves and providing objective evidence for the acupuncture theory of "regulating Qi and blood". Methods Healthy volunteers were recruited at Chinese PLA General Hospital from October to December 2025 and randomly divided into a deep needling group and a superficial needling group. ST36 was used in both groups. In the deep needling group, a filiform needle was inserted perpendicularly about 30 mm under ultrasound guidance to reach the branches of the anterior tibial artery, followed by lifting-thrusting manipulation for 150 seconds before withdrawal. In the superficial needling group, the needle was inserted about 10 mm without reaching the blood vessel and without any manipulation. Electrocardiogram and continuous blood pressure signals were simultaneously collected for 5 minutes at five time points: before needling (T1), during needling (T2), immediately after needling (T3), 30 min (T4) and 120 min (T5) after needling. HRV, BPV, and CO were analyzed, and BRS was analyzed using transfer function analysis. Results A total of 68 subjects were enrolled, including 34 in the deep needling group (15 males, 19 females, mean age 26.2±3.2 years) and 34 in the superficial needling group (16 males, 18 females, mean age 25.5±3.3 years). There were no statistically significant differences in age or gender between the two groups (P>0.05). In terms of HRV, the deep acupuncture group showed significantly higher natural logarithm of the root mean square of successive RR interval differences (lnRMSSD) at T2, T3, and T4 compared with T1 (all P<0.01), while no significant difference was found between T5 and T1 (P>0.05); the shallow acupuncture group exhibited no significant differences in lnRMSSD at any time points relative to T1 (all P>0.05), whereas between-group comparison revealed that ΔT2 (change from T1 to T2) in lnRMSSD was significantly greater in the deep acupuncture group than in the shallow acupuncture group (0.35±0.31 vs 0.13±0.32, P<0.01). Regarding BPV, the deep acupuncture group demonstrated significantly increased systolic blood pressure standard deviation (SBP-SD) and coefficient of variation (SBP-CV) at T2 compared with T1 (both P<0.01), with no other time points differing significantly from T1 (all P>0.05); the shallow acupuncture group showed no significant changes in any BPV parameter across all time points relative to T1 (all P>0.05), yet between-group analysis indicated that at T2, SBP-SD and SBP-CV in the deep acupuncture group were significantly higher than those in the shallow acupuncture group SBP-SD: (6.5±2.6) mmHg vs (4.9±1.4) mmHg; SBP-CV: 0.057±0.021 vs 0.042±0.011, both P<0.01. For cardiac output (CO), no significant interaction effect was observed (P>0.05), although a significant time effect was present (P<0.05), with post hoc pairwise comparisons showing that CO at T2, T3, and T4 was significantly lower than at T1 (P<0.05 or P<0.01). Concerning baroreflex sensitivity (BRS), the deep acupuncture group had significantly elevated BRS gain at T3 compared with T1 (P<0.05), whereas the shallow acupuncture group exhibited no significant differences in BRS gain across any time points relative to T1 (all P>0.05); between-group comparison demonstrated that BRS gain at T3 was significantly higher in the deep acupuncture group than in the shallow acupuncture group (10.66 6.81, 17.76 ms/mmHg vs 8.37 7.03, 10.50 ms/mmHg, P<0.05). Conclusion Deep needling at Zusanli regulates autonomic nerves for both the heart and blood vessels. For blood vessels, it mainly manifests a sympathetic effect; for the heart, it mainly manifests a parasympathetic effect. This study may provide a preliminary clinical reference for the treatment of cardiovascular diseases such as sinus tachycardia, cardiac neurosis, and orthostatic hypotension.

     

/

返回文章
返回