脊髓圆锥轨迹测距定位法对胎儿脊髓拴系的诊断价值

Diagnostic value of trace method of ultrasound examination for locating conus medullaris in fetal tethered spinal cord

  • 摘要:
      背景  脊髓圆锥(conus medullaris,CM)是指脊髓末端膨大的结构,其位置对判断是否存在脊髓拴系(tethered spinal cord,TC)具有十分重要的意义。目前产前超声检查中已有多种方法对CM位置进行定位,但在实际应用中仍然缺乏一种准确、有效的判断方法。
      目的  探讨轨迹法CD值对CM定位的作用及其在胎儿TC诊断中的应用价值。
      方法  收集2020年10月- 2021年10月在解放军总医院第一医学中心超声诊断科进行产前超声检查的正常胎儿资料,通过轨迹法测量CM末端与脊柱最远端骨化中心之间的距离,所测数值记为轨迹法CD值,对轨迹法CD值与孕龄(gestational age,GA)进行直线回归分析,得出二者间的直线回归方程。收集2015年3月- 2021年12月在同一科室进行产前超声检查并经胎儿MRI或引产后病理证实为TC的患儿资料为病例组。收集2014年9月- 2021年8月在同一科室进行产前超声检查并经胎儿MRI或引产后病理证实为脊柱病变但不伴有TC的患儿资料为对照组。评估轨迹法CD值在胎儿TC诊断中的应用价值。
      结果  正常组纳入1 172例,得出了各孕周超声检查轨迹法CD值的正常范围及其与孕龄间的直线回归方程:轨迹法CD值=0.037GA-2.275(R2=0.885,P<0.001)。病例组纳入26例,对照组纳入23例,以轨迹法CD值小于同孕龄胎儿第5百分位数为诊断标准,其对胎儿TC诊断的敏感度、特异性、阳性预测值、阴性预测值和准确率分别为100.0%(26/26)、82.6%(19/23)、86.7%(26/30)、100.0%(19/19)、91.8%(45/49)。对轨迹法CD值方法与金标准方法进行关联性检验(P<0.001),提示两种方法结果有明显关联。对二者进行优势性检验,差异无统计学意义(P=0.134),即金标准方法相比轨迹法CD值法的优势不显著。
      结论  轨迹法CD值能够准确、直观地显示CM位置,有助于在产前超声检查中快速判断是否存在CM低位,对胎儿TC的检出有较大意义。

     

    Abstract:
      Background  Conus medullaris (CM) refers to the enlarged structure at the end of the spinal cord, and its position is very important to the diagnosis of tethered spinal cord (TC). At present, there are many methods to locate CM during prenatal ultrasound examination, but these methods are not accurate and effective in practical application.
      Objective  To explore a new method to locate CM through prenatal ultrasound and evaluate its diagnostic performance in fetal TC.
      Methods  The data of fetuses undergoing prenatal ultrasound examinations with normal findings from October 2020 to October 2021 in the Department of Ultrasound Diagnosis of the First Medical Center of Chinese PLA General Hospital were retrospectively collected. On the transabdominal ultrasound image, the distance between the end of the CM and the most distal ossification center of the spine was measured by trace method and the measured value was recorded as the CD value of trace method. Linear regression analysis on the CD value of trace method and gestational age was performed to obtain the linear regression equation. The fetuses who were diagnosed as TC by MRI or pathology from March 2015 to December 2021 in our department were retrospectively enrolled as the case group; and the fetuses who were diagnosed with spinal lesions without TC by MRI or pathology from September 2014 to August 2021 were enrolled as control group. The diagnostic capacity of the CD value of trace method for fetal TC was explored.
      Results  We enrolled 1 172 normal fetus. The normal ranges of the CD value of trace method during each gestational age were evaluated. The linear regression analysis of the CD value of trace method and GA was performed to obtain the linear regression equation: the CD value of trace method =0.037GA-2.275 (R2=0.885, P<0.001). The case group included 26 fetuses, and the control group included 23 fetuses. When the CD value of trace method was lower than the 5th percentile, the fetus was diagnosed as TC. The sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value, negative predictive value and diagnostic accuracy of this method were 100% (26/26), 82.61% (19/23), 86.67% (26/30), 100% (19/19), 91.84% (45/49), respectively. The correlation test was carried out on the CD value of trace method and the gold standard method, indicating that the results of the two methods were obviously correlated( P<0.001). The superiority test of the two methods was conducted, and the difference was not significant (P=0.134), which meant the gold standard method had no significant advantage over the CD value of trace method.
      Conclusion  The CD value of trace method can illustrate the location of the CM accurately and intuitively, which helps to quickly determine whether there is a low position of the CM during the prenatal ultrasound examination, and is of great significance to the detection of the fetal TC.

     

/

返回文章
返回